Indiana Banks

90 FDIC-insured banks · Average health score 44/100 · 3 failures since 2000

A
2
banks
B
16
banks
C
25
banks
D
14
banks
F
33
banks

Banking in Indiana — What the FDIC Data Shows

Indiana is home to 90 FDIC-insured banks holding a combined $213.8B in total assets and $171.2B in customer deposits. The average PlainBankData health score across all Indiana banks is 44/100, derived from four FDIC Call Report metrics: Tier 1 Capital Ratio, Return on Assets, Texas Ratio, and Efficiency Ratio. The largest institution headquartered in the state is Old National Bank of Evansville, with $71.8B in assets and a health grade of C.

Looking at the grade distribution, 18 banks (20%) earn an A or B grade — signaling strong capital ratios and healthy profitability — while 25 sit at Grade C (meeting regulatory minimums with some areas to monitor) and 47 (52%) carry a D or F grade, indicating notable financial weaknesses in one or more of the four scoring pillars. Since 2000, Indiana has seen 3 bank failures tracked on the FDIC Failed Bank List. Most of those failures clustered during the 2008–2010 financial crisis, with resolution typically handled through acquisition by a stronger institution.

Not financial advice. These figures are drawn from public FDIC Call Reports and the FDIC Failed Bank List. Health grades are PlainBankData's interpretation of regulatory filings, not official FDIC ratings or endorsements. A lower grade does not mean your money is at risk — every dollar on deposit at any FDIC-insured bank is protected up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category, regardless of the institution's financial condition. For decisions about where to hold deposits or business funds, consult a qualified financial professional and verify figures directly at the FDIC's BankFind Suite.

Bank Assets Grade
Old National Bank $71.8B C
Merchants Bank of Indiana $19.4B B
First Merchants Bank $19.0B C
Centier Bank $9.7B B
1st Source Bank $9.1B B
German American Bank $8.4B B
Lake City Bank $7.0B B
Horizon Bank $6.4B D
United Fidelity Bank, fsb $6.3B F
First Financial Bank, National Association $5.7B B
First Internet Bank of Indiana $5.5B F
First Farmers Bank & Trust Co. $3.4B B
STAR Financial Bank $3.2B C
The National Bank of Indianapolis $3.1B C
Peoples Bank $2.0B D
First Bank Richmond $1.5B C
Farmers State Bank $1.3B A
First Harrison Bank $1.3B F
The Farmers Bank, Frankfort, Indiana $1.1B F
First Bank of Berne $1.1B B
Jackson County Bank $1.1B D
Community First Bank of Indiana $933M C
Citizens State Bank of New Castle, Indiana $891M C
Greenfield Banking Company $890M D
State Bank $865M C
First State Bank of Middlebury $813M B
FCN Bank, National Association $793M C
The North Salem State Bank $776M B
The New Washington State Bank $764M F
Citizens Bank $696M C
The Fountain Trust Company $676M B
First Federal Savings Bank $673M C
Springs Valley Bank & Trust Company $644M C
DeMotte State Bank $610M F
First Federal Savings Bank $605M D
Crossroads Bank $587M C
Freedom Bank $579M B
Community State Bank $572M C
First Federal Savings Bank $559M F
The Friendship State Bank $555M C
The Napoleon State Bank $483M F
The Peoples State Bank $482M F
Alliance Bank $462M D
Security Federal Savings Bank $458M F
The Hometown Savings Bank $458M D
Home Bank SB $433M F
The Bippus State Bank $428M B
First National Bank $426M D
The First National Bank of Monterey $418M F
Kentland Bank $407M F
The Garrett State Bank $394M B
Owen County State Bank $390M C
Grant County State Bank $389M A
American Community Bank of Indiana $381M C
The Riddell National Bank $366M C
The Campbell & Fetter Bank $355M C
Hoosier Heartland State Bank $352M D
Mutual Savings Bank $349M C
Bath State Bank $337M D
The Peoples Bank $319M B
Farmers and Merchants Bank $305M C
Tri-County Bank & Trust Company $296M F
Bedford Federal Savings Bank $286M F
Bank of Wolcott $275M D
Logansport Savings Bank $265M F
Union Savings and Loan Association $258M F
Wayne Bank and Trust Co. $251M D
Peoples Trust and Savings Bank $245M F
Hendricks County Bank and Trust Company $235M F
The Farmers and Merchants Bank $210M C
Fowler State Bank $203M F
LNB Community Bank $187M C
The Home National Bank of Thorntown $183M F
Community State Bank $173M C
First State Bank of Porter $158M F
First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Greensburg $151M D
Community State Bank $151M F
First Federal Savings Bank of Angola $138M F
ClearPoint Federal Bank & Trust $135M F
Spencer County Bank $131M F
Farmers and Mechanics Federal Savings Bank $117M F
CentreBank $112M F
First Federal Savings Bank of Washington $95M F
Scottsburg Building and Loan Association $76M D
Boonville Federal Savings Bank $69M C
The Fairmount State Bank $58M F
Peoples Community Bank SB of Monticello, Indiana $44M F
Everence Trust Company $15M B
Kentland Federal Savings and Loan Association $4M F
Generations Community Bank F

How to Read the Indiana Bank Directory

This page lists every FDIC-insured bank with a primary regulatory address in Indiana. Inclusion does not depend on charter type — both state-chartered and nationally-chartered banks appear here when the FDIC institution directory places their headquarters in this state. Branch locations, ATM networks, and credit unions are NOT in scope; this is a headquarters-anchored view. The 90 institutions shown reflect the most recent quarterly FDIC release; counts will change at each refresh as institutions merge, are acquired, or close.

Health Grade Interpretation

Each bank's letter grade (A through F) is computed from four FDIC-reported metrics: Tier 1 capital ratio, return on assets, the Texas Ratio (non-performing assets ÷ tangible capital), and the efficiency ratio. Grades are relative — every quarter we recompute thresholds against the full FDIC universe, so a "B" today may have been an "A" last cycle if the median improved. Across Indiana, 18 institutions (20%) currently sit in the A or B band, while 47 (52%) fall in the D or F band. The C cluster — the broad middle — typically captures roughly half of any state's banks and is not a warning signal on its own.

What State Concentration Tells You

Banks register their headquarters in Indiana for several distinct reasons: regional community service (the bulk of small community banks), favorable trust law (a handful of states attract large national fiduciary operations), regulatory familiarity, or historic charter inheritance. A high concentration of total assets in a single state — South Dakota, Delaware, and Ohio are well-known examples — usually reflects a few very large institutions choosing the state for tax or regulatory reasons, not breadth of local banking competition. Below the top of the table, the long tail of mid-sized and community banks gives a clearer picture of local market structure.

When Failures Matter

Since 2000, 3 banks headquartered in Indiana have failed. Every depositor at those banks was made whole up to the standard FDIC insurance ceiling (currently $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category, per institution). Bank failures cluster around macro events (the 2008-2010 wave, the regional bank stress of 2023) rather than steady attrition, so a clean recent record at the state level does not imply state-level safety — it usually reflects the absence of a triggering shock. The "Under Stress" ranking is more useful for forward-looking comfort than the historical failure count, because it scores current capital and credit-loss capacity.

Sources, Refresh Cadence, and Corrections

Every figure on this page derives from the FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile and the FDIC Institution Directory, both of which are public-domain government datasets. We re-pull the data on the FDIC's schedule (a quarterly release plus monthly institution-directory delta files for merger and closure events). Asset and capital figures are reported as of the most recent quarter-end and lag the calendar by approximately ninety days — this is the FDIC's reporting lag, not ours. If a specific bank record looks wrong (renaming, merger, missing fields), the contact page accepts corrections; we reconcile them against the source feed at the next refresh.

Related

Data sourced from official U.S. government datasets. See our methodology for details. Retrieved and formatted by PlainBankData Editorial