FDIC Cert #28712 · Middletown, New York · Est. 1888

First Federal Savings of Middletown - FDIC Bank Health Profile

A community-scale look at First Federal Savings of Middletown's own numbers, pulled straight from its quarterly FDIC Call Report.

Compiled from official public sources by the publisher.
$182M
Total assets
A
Health grade · Excellent
1.86%
Return on assets
37.0%
Tier 1 capital

Data updated July 2026

The verdict

First Federal Savings of Middletown earns a PlainBankData health grade of A (97/100), with well-capitalized at 36.97% Tier 1, profitable at 1.86% ROA, efficient (52% cost ratio).

#3,143
largest of 4,313 FDIC banks by assets
27th
percentile by asset size, nationally
36.97%
Tier 1 ratio - above the 10% well-capitalized line
87th
percentile for profitability (ROA), nationally

The grade above reflects PlainBankData's own read of the bank's regulatory filings, not an FDIC judgment, deposit coverage stays at $250,000 per depositor, per category, unaffected by it.

FDIC Call Report plate

Cert 28712 · NY A · 97/100

GRADE-A · TOP-DECILE · PHOTO-FINISH · TIER1-WELL · TEXAS-CLEAN · ROA-STRONG · SIZE-MID · BOOK-FULL

  • GRADE-A A (97/100)
  • TOP-DECILE #235/4307
  • PHOTO-FINISH First Piedmont Feder… · SC
  • TIER1-WELL 37.0% Tier 1
  • TEXAS-CLEAN 0.5% Texas
  • ROA-STRONG 1.86% ROA
  • SIZE-MID $100M–1B
  • BOOK-FULL 9/9 fields

Nearest health peer outside New York: First Piedmont Federal Savings and Loan Association of Gaffney, SC (±0 health pts)

Instrument codes from this bank’s FDIC Call Report sheet: grade band, health peer rank, photo-finish gap, Tier 1, Texas Ratio, ROA, size band, and book completeness. Not an official FDIC rating.

Health-score neighbourhood around First Federal Savings of Middletown

Lowest and highest poles plus nearest scored peers outside New York, not a full FDIC corpus board reprint.

Morgan Stanley Bank,… · UT ·…100/100BancFirst · OK · near97/100Burling Bank · IL · near97/100First Federal Saving… · NY ·…97/100First Piedmont Feder… · SC ·…97/100Timberland Bank · WA · near97/100Tioga-Franklin Savin… · PA ·…0/100
PlainBankData health composite · neighbourhood around First Federal Savings of Middletown · July 2026

What First Federal Savings of Middletown's Call Report plate shows

First Federal Savings of Middletown (FDIC Cert #28712) carries a PlainBankData health grade of A at 97/100, built only from this bank's own Call Report Tier 1 capital, ROA, Texas Ratio, and efficiency inputs. On the scored corpus it sits at health rank #235 of 4,307. Tier 1 capital prints at 36.97%, clearing the 10% well-capitalized line. The Texas Ratio is 0.51%, inside the sub-50% band analysts treat as healthy. Return on assets is 1.86%. Balance-sheet scale is $182M, 3,143rd of 4,313 FDIC-insured banks by assets. The nearest cross-state health peer is First Piedmont Federal Savings and Loan Association of Gaffney (SC), tied on the composite. These are instrument codes from the Call Report sheet, not an official FDIC CAMELS rating, and insured deposits stay protected to $250,000 per depositor per ownership category regardless of grade. Compare the plate stamps against the score breakdown and the health-score neighbourhood before treating any single ratio as decisive.

State failure history around First Federal Savings of Middletown

6 FAILURE resolutions in New York since 2000 (5 since 2008)

First Federal Savings of Middletown's home state sits in the middle band of post-2000 FAILURE counts (6; 5 since the 2008 crisis window). Recent named resolutions below are Failed Bank List rows for this state only; First Federal Savings of Middletown remains an active FDIC-insured reporter.

  • SIGNATURE BANK NEW YORK, NY 2023 → FLAGSTAR BANK, N.A.
  • USA BANK PORT CHESTER, NY 2010 → NEW CENTURY BANK
  • THE PARK AVENUE BANK NEW YORK, NY 2010 → VALLEY NATIONAL BANK

Source: FDIC Failed Bank List (resolution_type=FAILURE only; ASSISTANCE excluded). See the depositor failures guide and New York banks.

How First Federal Savings of Middletown's 97/100 score adds up

Each factor is scored from this bank's own FDIC Call Report figures, then summed to the composite health score.

0/100100/100National avg77/10097/100
First Federal Savings of Middletown's composite health score
Tier 1 Capital Ratio (36.97%) 40/40
Return on Assets (ROA) (1.86%) 25/25
Texas Ratio (0.51%) 20/20
Efficiency Ratio (51.98%) 12/15

97 of 100 points earned across four weighted factors. See our methodology for the full scoring formula.

Balance sheet at a glance

Total Assets

$182M

Total balance-sheet footings

Total Deposits

$108M

Customer-funded liabilities

Net Loans

$152M

Outstanding loan book

Net Income

$3M

Bottom-line earnings

Capital adequacy vs federal thresholds

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% CET1 (≥6.5% req.) Tier 1 (≥8.0% req.) Total (≥10.0% req.) 35.57% 36.97% 38.37%
Basel III capital ratios - First Federal Savings of Middletown

Where First Federal Savings of Middletown ranks

Every one of the 4,307 FDIC-insured banks with a computed health score, bucketed by score. First Federal Savings of Middletown's score of 97/100 falls in the highlighted band.

First Federal Savings of Middletown: health score vs. every FDIC-insured bank

0-100 composite health score, FDIC Call Reports

97 Top 5% higher than 95% of 4,307 FDIC-insured banks

0–10: 3 FDIC-insured banks (0%). Below this entry. 10–20: 6 FDIC-insured banks (0%). Below this entry. 20–30: 26 FDIC-insured banks (1%). Below this entry. 30–40: 36 FDIC-insured banks (1%). Below this entry. 40–50: 98 FDIC-insured banks (2%). Below this entry. 50–60: 279 FDIC-insured banks (6%). Below this entry. 60–70: 777 FDIC-insured banks (18%). Below this entry. 70–80: 1,030 FDIC-insured banks (24%). Below this entry. 80–90: 1,237 FDIC-insured banks (29%). Below this entry. 90–100: 815 FDIC-insured banks (19%). This entry sits in this band. First Federal Savings of Middletown 0 100 every FDIC-insured bank with a health score, bucketed by value

Each bar is a band; taller bars hold more FDIC-insured banks. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.

Source FDIC Call Reports · July 2026

First Federal Savings of Middletown's size among FDIC-insured banks

Every one of the 4,307 FDIC-insured banks with reported assets, bucketed by total-asset scale (note the buckets are powers of 10, most banks cluster in the $100M-$1B range). First Federal Savings of Middletown's $182M falls in the highlighted band.

Safety ratios for First Federal Savings of Middletown

Tier 1 capital ratio
Well-capitalized 10%

36.97% of risk-weighted assets - above the federal "well-capitalized" threshold of 10%.

Tier 1 Capital Ratio
36.97%
Texas Ratio
0.51%
Equity Capital
$67M

What these ratios mean →

Earnings posture at First Federal Savings of Middletown

Return on Assets (ROA)
87th percentile nationally
1.86%
Return on Equity (ROE)
5.14%
Efficiency Ratio
51.98%

What these mean →

Income & expense at First Federal Savings of Middletown

$11M
Interest Income
$183K
Non-Interest Income
$5M
Non-Interest Expense

Asset quality, Texas Ratio detail

The Texas Ratio compares troubled assets to the capital available to absorb losses. First Federal Savings of Middletown reports a Texas Ratio of 0.51% - comfortably in the healthy band; non-performing loans are a small fraction of the bank’s loss-absorbing capital.

Texas Ratio
Caution 50%

0.51% - lower is safer; 100% is the level at which troubled assets equal loss-absorbing capital.

FDIC Failed Bank List → View First Federal Savings of Middletown on FDIC BankFind →

Top banks in New York by total assets

Largest banks headquartered in New York
  1. 1
    Goldman Sachs Bank USA $645.0B

    New York, NY · Grade A

  2. 2
    The Bank of New York Mellon $381.0B

    New York, NY · Grade A

  3. 3
    Morgan Stanley Private Bank $254.7B

    Purchase, NY · Grade A

  4. 4
    Manufacturers and Traders Trust Compa… $212.9B

    Buffalo, NY · Grade A

  5. 5
    Flagstar Bank $87.5B

    Hicksville, NY · Grade D

Top 5 banks in New York ranked by total assets · FDIC Call Report Q4 2025.

Nationwide banks with similar total assets

Nearest other-state banks with ≥$10M assets ($182M here), outside New York so the neighborhood is not state containment.

Farmers and Merchants State Bank $182M · SD The Solomon State Bank $182M · KS The State Savings Bank of Manistique $182M · MI F&M Bank and Trust Company $182M · MO

Source: FDIC BankFind Suite, Call Report (FFIEC 031/041) First Federal Savings of Middletown (FDIC Cert #28712) - Tier 1 capital ratio, total assets, deposits, ROA/ROE · 2025 FDIC Call Reports filed quarterly; latest publicly-available vintage shown. Health grades are PlainBankData's interpretation of regulatory filings and are not official FDIC ratings.

First Federal Savings of Middletown Call Report profile · FDIC Failed Bank List · New York FAILURE history · Informational only, not financial advice; consult a licensed professional before acting. See the disclaimer and methodology.

Other banks in New York

All New York banks →
BankAssetsGradeROA
Goldman Sachs Bank USANew York $645.0B A 1.42%
The Bank of New York MellonNew York $381.0B A 1.31%
Morgan Stanley Private Bank, National AssociationPurchase $254.7B A 1.10%
Manufacturers and Traders Trust CompanyBuffalo $212.9B A 1.40%
Flagstar Bank, National AssociationHicksville $87.5B D -0.14%
Bank of ChinaNew York $61.9B F 0.00%
Deutsche Bank Trust Company AmericasNew York $43.0B A 1.86%
State Bank of IndiaNew York $22.6B F 0.00%